Timber Wars

Listen: ‘Timber Wars,’ a new podcast from OPB

By Aaron Scott (OPB)
Sept. 1, 2020 5:05 p.m. Updated: Sept. 22, 2020 6:10 p.m.

OPB’s seven-episode podcast “Timber Wars” tells the story of how a small group of activists and scientists turned a fight over ancient trees and the spotted owl into one of the biggest environmental conflicts of the 20th century, and in the process redefined the very way we see—and fight over—the natural world.

It’s the 1990s in the Pacific Northwest. A march of chainsaws clear-cuts the country’s last available ancient forests. Protesters bury themselves in front of bulldozers and spend months sitting in the tallest trees in the world. And at the center, the Northern Spotted Owl becomes the most controversial bird in the country.

Hosted and produced by OPB’s Aaron Scott in collaboration with 30 Minutes West (“Bundyville,” “Outside Podcast”) and with original music by the singer-songwriter Laura Gibson, “Timber Wars” is a seven-part podcast series from Oregon Public Broadcasting. Episodes are available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, the NPR One app and at opb.org.

THANKS TO OUR SPONSOR:

“Timber Wars“ tells the behind-the-scenes story of how a small group of activists and scientists turned the fight over ancient trees and a bird that no one had heard about into one of the biggest environmental conflicts of the 20th century.

In addition to the podcast, OPB is releasing an accompanying e-newsletter series that combines the podcast with further OPB reporting to take readers through the history of this epic battle — and explores the ways it’s playing out still — in stories, images, videos and more.

Related: Subscribe to the "Timber Wars" special newsletter series


Episode 1: The last stand

When loggers headed into the forest on Easter Sunday in 1989, they found a line of protesters blocking the road. The ensuing battle would help catapult old-growth forests into a national issue, and become known as the “Easter Massacre.”

Episode 2: The forest

For most of America’s history, trees were seen as crops, and the plan was to log the country’s last virgin forests and make them de facto tree farms. We see forests very differently today. How did things change so quickly?

Episode 3: The owl

Depending on who you are, the northern spotted owl is either the hero of this story, or the villain. And the Endangered Species Act is either an incredible conservation tool, or a hammer that smashes rural economies. But those beliefs miss the fact that it was a single sentence in an entirely different law that locked up the forests. How a reclusive bird halted the march of chainsaws.

Episode 4: Mill City

Mill City was one of dozens of flourishing timber towns, where a job in the woods or at the local sawmill could support a good life. But protests and court cases upended that, leaving locals to ask: are owls more endangered than loggers?

Episode 5: The plan

The Timber Wars grew so hot that one of President Clinton’s first acts in office was to fly half his cabinet to Portland to resolve the conflict. The result was the Northwest Forest Plan, the most sweeping conservation plan in U.S. history. But it might never have happened if not for some behind-the-scenes dramas that played out in a Capitol Hill bathroom-turned-office and a presidential lunch buffet.

Episode 6: The backlash

Before the Northwest Forest Plan had a chance to succeed, Congress seized upon the threat of wildfires to create a loophole and throw the plan out the window. With old growth once again being logged, the fight to defend it grew both more mainstream and more violent, seeding the tactics for conflicts to come.

Episode 7: A way forward

Is the Northwest fatally divided, or can we overcome our differences and work together? We tell the story of one group of loggers and environmentalists, the Blue Mountains Forest Partners, who have found some semblance of common ground. But it didn’t come easy. And no one knows how long it’ll last. Is there a way to manage our forests that’s good for forests and small towns?

Bonus Episode: Big money bought the forest

While we’ve focused on national forests in “Timber Wars,” our colleague Tony Schick was partnering with ProPublica and The Oregonian to investigate one of its modern-day consequences: the rise of investment portfolio ownership of Oregon’s private forests, and how this has impacted rural communities. Because despite the belief that the spotted owl shut down the forests, big timber corporations have continued cutting trees; they just do it on private land while employing fewer people and contributing much less back to the local economies.


Additional reading/watching list

Reportage

Big money bought Oregon’s forests. Small timber communities are paying the price.” by Tony Schick, Rob Davis and Lylla Younes

How a public institute in Oregon became a de facto lobbying arm of the timber industry” by Tony Schick, Rob Davis and Lylla Younes

Last Call: Tracking The Sound Of The Spotted Owl’s Extinction” by Ian McCluskey

Old Growth Could Be Key For Native Songbird Species To Beat Climate-Change Heat” by Jes Burns (filmed in the HJ Andrews Experimental Forest)

Flames of Dissent” series by Kera Abraham, Eugene Weekly

Books

“Tree Huggers: Victory, Defeat & Renewal in the Northwest Ancient Forest Campaign” by Kathie Durbin

“Final Forest: The Battle for the Last Great Trees of the Pacific Northwest” by William Dietrich

THANKS TO OUR SPONSOR:

“Showdown at Opal Creek: The Battle for America’s Last Wilderness” by David Seideman

“The Wisdom of the Spotted Owl: Policy Lessons for a New Century” by Steven Lewis Yaffee

“The Hidden Forest: The Biography of an Ecosystem” by Jon R. Luoma (about the HJ Andrews Experimental Forest)

“In a Dark Wood” by Alston Chase

“Empire of Timber: Labor Unions and the Pacific Northwest Forests” by Erik Loomis

“The Overstory: A Novel” by Richard Powers

Documentaries

Mill City” by OPB

Rage Over Trees” by the Audubon Society

Research

Of Spotted Owls, Old Growth, and New Policies: A History Since the Interagency Scientific Committee Report” by Bruce G. Marcot and Jack Ward Thomas

Travels with Strix: The Spotted Owl’s Journey through the Federal Courts” by Victor Sher

Seattle Audubon Soc. v. Evans” by Judge William Dwyer

The Ecological Characteristics of Old Growth Douglas Fir Forests” by Jerry Franklin et al.

Forest Ecosystem Management: An Ecological, Economic, and Social Assessment” by Jack Ward Thomas et al. [Executive Summary]

The Northwest Forest Plan: Origins, Components, Implementation Experience, and Suggestions for Change” by Jack Ward Thomas et al.

25 Years After the NW Forest Plan: What Have We Learned” by Tom Spies et al.

Credits

Written and reported by Aaron Scott, with editing from Peter Frick-Wright, Robbie Carver, David Steves and Ed Jahn

Produced by Aaron Scott and Peter Frick-Wright and Robbie Carver of 30 Minutes West

Music composed and performed by Laura Gibson

Sound design by Robbie Carver

Mastering by Steven Kray

Fact checking by Matt Giles

Legal oversight by Rebecca Morris

Marketing and publicity by Jennifer McCormick and Lauren Elkanich

Research help from Erin Ross

Executive Producer Ed Jahn

Archival footage

Born in Fire

C-Span

KATU-TV

KDRV-TV

KEZI-TV/Chambers Communication Corporation records, Coll 427, Special Collections & University Archives, University of Oregon Libraries.

NPR

PBS Newshour

“Pickaxe: The Cascadia Free State Story”

Special thanks

All the people who shared their stories and time with us

NPR Story Lab Program: Michael May, Cara Tallo, Matt Ozug, Katie Daugert, Adelina Lancianese, Sam Leeds

Jenna Molster & Daniel Wood, Rights & Permissions, NPR

Nathan Georgitis & Lauren Goss, University of Oregon Libraries, Special Collections & University Archives

Steve Bass, Jes Burns, Lauren Dake, Anna Griffin, Jan Boyd, Julie Feely, Ryan Haas, Morgan Holm, Anne Ibach, Cheryl Ikemiya, Laurie Isola, Andy Lee, Crystal Ligori, Jeff Mapes, Ian McCluskey, Geoff Norcross, Marci Ozawa, Anthony Schick, Nalin Silva, Eric Slade, Todd Sonflieth, Brandon Swanson, Stephanie Stewart, Ann Suckow, Sage Van Wing, Bryan Vance, Dirk VanderHart, Todd Witter, and everyone else at OPB who helped with this project

The Timber Wars newsletter.


THANKS TO OUR SPONSOR:
THANKS TO OUR SPONSOR: